Originally posted by: Indigo_Streetlight
Originally posted by: MalcolmXY
BUT
if these gamers don't care about playing an emulation vs a cartridge, and the artwork is scanned and saved on multiple servers (as almost all of them are, especially those for any Nintendo console), then what's the point of owning the cartridge?
There are differences in terms of ease of use; to me a physical manual is more immediate and easier to read than shuffling through a scan in pdf form. The same goes for cartridges vs. emulations in most cases; I'll admit there's a few RPGs which benefit from save states, however for action games or platformers the original hardware is where it's at. There's a bunch of other variables which go with the pc use too: hunched posture, internet noise, having to configure or use different controls. If enough nonsense gets in the way of the pure experience then emulation just isn't worth it.
I believe, if taken in context, my quote went to the ridiculous claim of keeping sealed games for the sake of preservation and posterity, and had nothing to do with the practicality for the everyday collector/gamer.
I'm down with the collecting and playing on the original hardware (it's not for me anymore, but I think it's perfectly cool for those who choose to do it).
Going back to my statement in context, however - I'd still say it's easier to read a .pdf of a game manual than it would be to rip open a $5,000 sealed game, when doing so would reduce it's value by 90%.
Also, it's been a while since I've used NESter, or even had it on my PC, but I seem to remember easy, savable settings, and with the advent of USB classic controllers from nearly all systems, I fail to see how, with a $15 controller and 2 minutes of one's time, the experience of playing a ROM file via an emulator would be different than playing a cartridge with a ROM chip/board on your TV (internet noise? the ROM should be on a local storage device like a hard drive, DVD-ROM or a thumb drive...what internet noise???).
Obviously this doesn't apply to games which use a zapper or similar such device, and also, I understand that CRT can be different than LED, et al, but otherwise, where's this difference of which you speak? (Put the monitor/laptop somewhere that it is at the same height as your TV, or at least the same height as your TV relative to where you typically sit in front of the TV when gaming on it, and on a PC with an emulator..."hunching" problem solved. That'll be $.05, please.)