Alright you don't have to go one by one here. The main one was Chubby Cherub, and while it does look worn, I've also seen much worse.

Assuming the rest of the games are in similar condition, I'd say anywhere from $200-$300 in value perhaps. Not sure of the exact market value on a worn Chubby Cherub.

This.

Especially with Chubby Cherub and Mario Bros. in that lot, you'd do better selling here.

It's like a potato threw up in here.

ok thank you all

That is about as helpful as a punch in the d*ck.

If you don't want to help move on.  These are very condition sensitive and posting pics here and asking (which is what the OP did) is much more reliable than searching eBay.  Way to be a terd.

You poor girl. If that person is offering you $100 for your games in the cardboard boxes just $100 he's trying to scam the hell out of you for not knowing better so he can turn around and sell them for a lot more. Chubby Cherub in the box isn't exactly cheap just to note the one game as it's a $20-35 game just for the cartridge alone, the box has considerable value depending how nice it is and it doesn't often come up as it's not in ebay's current complete/sold listings right now.

Tell him to go jump off a bridge into a dry ravine.

Chubby cherub will probably get you close to $100 on its own

Worth way more than $100.00. I would not accept less than $300.

Oh yeah....and tell that guy to go out on his front lawn, drop his pants, stick his wiener inside his own ass and tinkle inside himself.

Yeah chubby cherub is pretty hard to find especially in its box yours is in kinda rough shape. but its still worth more than the offer you got

Price Charting and Ebay are good tools to estimate value.

Edit... Check here as well.

I thought Chubby Cherub with box went for around $500?

Granted, $100 is significantly less than the full value, but for a Craigslist ad with blurry pics as a first offer it's really not that bad. Giving her the value is fine, but don't talk bad about some dude who was just making a first offer and act like you guys would do any different. $100 is hardly a "scam", nor is reselling a scam...that's how most businesses work. You buy something to sell it for more...

Who said the person who offered was running a business? I do agree that $100 is not a terrible first offer, he may not have had pics or the details about the boxes being included...

Its closer to $300 if really nice shape, which this one is not... 

Olivia, you should sell those here so you get top dollar instead of selling to someone who is most likely just going to turn around and sell them for more to make a quick buck. I would NA auction that chubby cherub if I was looking to sell. 

Yes, this too.

Sell it here. Ill buy the Chubby Cherub if your interested in selling.

For photos try photobucket.com or imgur.com and create a gallery. Probably easier than one at a time like your doing.

Dead right. If it was someone on this page who scored this for $100 and posted it in the Finders Keepers thread we would all be slapping them on the back and congratulating them right now.

Seriously, as if anyone here wouldn't jump at this listing, offer $100, get the deal and then brag in the 'Finder's Keepers' section, ending the post with: "everything is for sale" 

Ha, my thoughts exactly

Sure, we all like to make a profit, or get "steals" on things, but can't we be atleast fair when making offers to buy things? I know how much everyone hates Gamestop because they try to turn a 1000% profit on new games, so why should we do the same? You treat people with respect and you'll get respect back.

$100 is not a respectable offer to make, especially if everything is complete in box.

Lol at this thread, people that are getting upset because some guy was trying to get a hell of a deal are just people who are upset they do not get good cheap finds and had to pay a lot of $$$ for some top dollar games when some of us find them dirt cheap.

People here have said the value quit debating on morals and just stick to telling the value.

^ Yea honestly to you people bashing on this guy. Having the knowledge and the insight into knowing what these games are worth is something that is gained through experience. And that is what separates him from this woman crowd-sourcing and using us for a quick free consultation. He knows what they are worth she doesn't, and in the end if there was no internet she would have sold them for his best offer and both parties would be happy. Ignorance is bliss.

So get off your high horse. Yes there are a lot of d-bag re-sellers out there that have absolutely no passion for the games, they just want the profit. But I think $100 shows that this guy is at least trying to be reasonable, and it's a first offer he expected her to shoot back (if she knew) 150-200, and he hadn't even seen good pics of the stuff.

Nintendoage should charge people to post in the price check section if you have not been a member for X months. I understand the forum does not get a lot of attention but you all know this is one of the best sites for finding experts in this field. If people are not capable enough to find out information via search engines on their own they deserve to cough up some $$ if you are just here for a free ride.