I was doing some research and found this table (made by ALbailey and quoted by guillavoie in this thread)
Can this be considered the most updated list? If not, I can edit this one if any new ones have been found since and we can consider it the "definitive" list. The list I got from the aforementioned thread has a lot of other crazy stuff in it, and is rather old.
The Odd/variants thread located here has mentions and a lot of pics but its pretty convoluted and I was hoping for a nice clean list for our refrence and google searches.
Im not as concrened with the rarity numbers as they can be hard to prove and are subjective (might even remove them) but the "which is rarer" column is the perfect thing.
If you have any info to add please do so, but lets keep the discussion to NES 3-screw/ 5 screw variants.
<><>
| Title | 5 Screw | 3 Screw | Which is Rarer | |
| 10-Yard Fight | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| 1942 | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| 3-D Battles of World Runner, The | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Alpha Mission | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Arkanoid | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Athena | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Athletic World | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Balloon Fight | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Baseball | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Breakthru | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| BurgerTime | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Castlevania | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Chubby Cherub | Yes | No | NA | |
| Clu Clu Land | Yes | No | NA | |
| Commando | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Deadly Towers | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Devil World* | Yes | No | NA | |
| Donkey Kong | Yes | Yes | 3 screw | |
| Donkey Kong Jr. | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Donkey Kong Jr. Math | Yes | Yes | NA | |
| Donkey Kong | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Double Dribble | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Duck Hunt | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Elevator Action | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Excitebike | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Ghosts 'n Goblins | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Golf | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Goonies II, The | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Gradius | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Gumshoe | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Gyromite | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Hogan's Alley | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Ice Climber | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Ikari Warriors | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Jaws | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Karate Champ | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Kid Icarus | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Kid Niki: Radical Ninja | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Kung Fu | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Legend of Kage, The | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Legend of Zelda, The | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Lode Runner | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Lunar Pool | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| M.U.S.C.L.E. - Tag Team Match | Yes | No | NA | |
| Mach Rider | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Mah Jong* | Yes | No | NA | |
| Mario Bros., The Original | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Mega Man | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Metroid | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Mighty Bombjack | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Mike Tyson Punch Out | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Ninja Kid | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Pinball | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Popeye | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Pro Wrestling | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Rad Racer | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Raid on Bungeling Bay | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Ring King | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Rush'n Attack | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Rygar | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Section-Z | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Sky Kid | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Slalom | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Soccer | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Solomon's Key | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Spelunker | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Spy Hunter | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Sqoon | Yes | No | NA | |
| Stack-Up | Yes | No | NA | |
| Star Force | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Star Voyager | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Stinger | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Super Mario Bros. | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Super Pitfall | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Tag Team Wrestling | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Tennis | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Tiger-Heli | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Top Gun | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Track & Field | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Track & Field 2 | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Trojan | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Urban Champion | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Volleyball | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Wild Gunman | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Winter Games | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Wizards & Warriors | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw | |
| Wrecking Crew | Yes | Yes | 3 Screw | |
| Zanac | Yes | Yes | 5 Screw |
.png)