Found this ad on Craigslist for 65 NES commons CIB... most are in "very good" condition as stated by the seller.  He is asking $15 a piece... I asked him what he could do if I bought them all; all 65 games would end up being $975 if bought at $15/per.  He said he would do $13 per (which is $845)

The $845 figure is still a bit much for me as if I try to resell them, I doubt I'd get much more than $1000 (if that).

What do you guys think is a fair offer if I'm looking to resell them?

EDIT: haha forgot the essential part... the games!  Here they are:
8 Eyes
Adventures of Bayou Billy
Adventures of Dino Riki
American Gladiators
Anticipation
Astyanax
Back to the Future
Bigfoot
Breakthru
Captain Skyhawk
Castlequest
Code Name Viper
Cybernoid
Defender of the Crown
Flying Dragon
Destination Earthstar
Dynowarz
Faxanadu
Fester's Quest x2
Gauntlet 2
Golf
Golgo 13
Highspeed Pinball
Hogan's Alley
Hollywood Squares
Hoops
Hydlide
Irons word W&W2
Jeopardy 25th
Joust
Kabuki Quantum Fighter
Kings of the Beach
Kung Fu Heros
Legacy of the Wizard
Mission Impossible
Milon's Secret Castle
Mickey Mouse Capades
NES Open Golf
Rygar
PinBot
Q-Bert
RC Pro Am
Robocop
RadRacer 2
Shadowgate
Solar Jetman
Solstice
StarTropics
StarTropics 2 Zoda'a Revenge
Super Jeopardy
Super Pitfall
Swords and Serpents
Tetris 2
Tecmo Bowl
Tiger-Heli
The Black Bass
Total Recall
Ultima Exodus
Vindicators
Wheel of Fortune
Who Framed Roger Rabbit
Wrecking Crew
Yoshi
Yoshi's Cookie

In all honesty I don't see that as being worth your money or time.

CIB stuff is much harder to sell than cart only. How is the condition?

If you can get them for cart only prices, you may do okay.

x2


If it were me, Id try to work out a generous cart only price, unless they are all like really mint or in the same shape. Usually CIB stuff ranges though

He is a collector, so the condition is "at least 7/10" across the board.

I don't see us making a deal though, because as you said Jer, I don't see it being worth the time or cash.

I did spread the word of Nintendoage to him though!

...then I'd guess that this is what he has left after he sold all the desirable stuff. He's trying to offload the "crap" (granted, I love many of these titles, but they'll be hard / time-consuming to get rid of to make it worth your while). He'll surely find a buyer on craigslist that will jump on this. Likely somebody far less educated than you, which I'm sure is his hope


 

Are you going after a deal on his "rare titles"? Some good games in that section!

Id be jumping all over that Wrecking Crew for $15, there's some good ones in there, but not for a $13 a game average unless you can talk him down more.

If I were looking to buy that lot only to resell, I would offer somewhere in the $5 to $8 range. $8 would be pushing it.. I wouldn't go a penny more.. Would take awhile to move all of them..