Originally posted by: JosephLeo
Originally posted by: Portabello
Seriously, the guy spent 17k on a video game and you all won't let him put a repro label on the cart? I completely understand disrupting the collector zen with something that could be mistaken as original, but if it's clearly a reproduction, why get so offended? if a true collector is going to shell out that kind of money in the future, they would be stupid not to do their research. These aren't fake $20 bills floating around, you are worrying about someone who might accidentally spend 25k when they should have spent 17k. First world problems, let it go.
We're all just a bunch of nerds arguing about the semantics, philosophy, and ethics of game collecting.
Ultimately it's lagenfield's right to do what he wants with his stuff until he hands it down to the next guy. However, just as OP has his own rights, everone else has their own rights to positively, neutrally, or negatively form their own opinions on his actions.
Fact of the matter is, everyone now knows that the label is a reproduction label which is only good for the future of that specific cartridge.
no, i get ya, it's all for fun. I just don't personally see the repro label as something that truly 'de-values' the item. yeah it's bad karma to scam someone into paying a higher because of it's "pristine, original label", but I am talking about 'original value as is' vs. 'value with repro label affixed' i think they are equal, not worth anymore, not worth any less. it's still a 17k cart.
OP may be turning off certain purist collectors, and that's his risk, but ultimately I don't judge him for making a decision like that. He is the one who gets to look at and enjoy it the most, screw the future buyers