Originally posted by: Bert
Originally posted by: TuSecsy
They are making the best product they can, and that includes all the cores they can throw at it, as soon as they can throw at it. They can't say so publically and never will because it's ILLEGAL.... Notice how they always skate around the issue? There will be no limitations on what Kevtris does with this machine other than the limitations of the FPGA, none.
So, question. Why is it ok to sell this system with an SNES Core out of the box, but every other core is illegal?
It's not that playing the ROMs is "illegal." It isn't. It's more that they don't want there to be any question that this is primarily intended for legitimate use to play real games that people legitimately own. It only has an SNES slot, sooo... yeah.
In the past Nintendo blocked imports of perfectly legitimate unofficial N64 devkits by arguing that the "primary use" was for game piracy. The company disabled the backup function and allowed users to re-enable it with a "backup enabled" BIOS update, which you couldn't find on their website but could find in certain places literally the moment the original went live. This was before the DMCA.
Sometimes it's out of an abundance of caution. Galoob/Codemasters and their Game Genie were sued for making and profiting from derivative works of a copyrighted product but the US courts shot that down and allowed the Game Genie to exist.
Datel still feared exposing themselves to a similar lawsuit with the Action Replay so they disassociated themselves from their American distributor, Interact, and Interact released it under a different name ("GameShark"). Interact and Datel had public statements on their websites that their companies and products were different and had nothing to do with each other even though you could clearly see "Datel" inside a GameShark. Interact probably agreed to take on all responsibility for releasing it in the USA to limit Datel's potential liability.
Since the DMCA, several other devices have adopted similar techniques to avoid lawsuits. The ViperGC modchip could not play backups unless you loaded "unofficial" Cobra FW on it. Of course, "Cobra" was ready before the "Viper" mod chip was released! They acted like it was just an IPL for running Linux. A lot of XBOX mod chips were the same way.
Memor32 was basically a commercial version of the Free Memory Card Boot exploit for PS2 but they sold it as a USB memory card that could copy saves to/from your PC. They pretended that a separate Russian hacker group called "Team Memento" turned it into a piracy device that could boot backups and bootlegs. A real third-party hacker group would have known perfectly well how to install the same exploit on a standard memory card but, instead, it was restricted to the Memor32 until FMCB blew the lid open. The "unrelated hacker group" said that it required a Memor32 for some unspecified technical reason that they never divulged and that clearly was not true.
While a device that plays ROMs would not be illegal on its own unless it breaks a copy protection or violates a patent/copyright to do so (includes original BIOS or something), they don't want any trouble. Understandable.
Originally posted by: TuSecsy
Originally posted by: CZroe
Originally posted by: TuSecsy
There is no possible way there won't be all the NT mini cores and a SNES core at release or very soon after. The other 16-bit cores may take some time however.
@bouncekdelamos
You are literally describing the Super NT, preorder away
I wouldn't assume that. If the details of Kevin's deal with Analogue include royalties for each unit sold then Kevin has a vested interest in selling both. He also won't need to re-engineer the cartridge adapters he's already made.
Granted, I still wouldn't be interested in the NT Mini, but it wouldn't be all bad: it also gives him incentive to develop even more cores to differentiate the Super NT. If he wants people who weren't interested before to buy both then they'll have to make an NT Mini MkII/Lite with an even lower cost (or bundled adapter boards).
I love when greedy americans spew some nonsense they think they heard in business 101. Analogue (and definitely Kevtris) do not care about money 1st, they care about product 1st.
They are making the best product they can, and that includes all the cores they can throw at it, as soon as they can throw at it. They can't say so publically and never will because it's ILLEGAL.... Notice how they always skate around the issue? There will be no limitations on what Kevtris does with this machine other than the limitations of the FPGA, none.
"The whole beginning of Analogue and the kind of products we've wanted to make is this holy grail, end-all, pedestal sort of thing," Analogue CEO and founder Christopher Taber tells me during a Skype call from Hong Kong, where the company keeps a second office to monitor its supply chain. "It's a have every single feature and every single detail you can possibly imagine and make it as good as it can possibly be mindset. You don't see a lot of products in any category that do that, because obviously that ends up making them very expensive."
If anyone wants to bet me the NT mini cores won't be ported to this thing immediately or shortly after release, I'm taking all comers, as much as you wanna bet...
Dude. I'm probably more excited for this than you but you're totally stepping on my toes too. I'm "greedy" because I acknowledge that Kevin and Analogue are running a business?
It seems that you don't know me very well.
All I'm saying is that we can't assume it will get the same cores when there could be a reason why they wouldn't. I didn't say that they wouldn't or even say that they probably wouldn't. I still think that they probably WILL give us all the cores. It's a huge leap to go from "I think they probably will but might not because [possible reasons]" to "I'll bet money against you that they won't," so it's safe to say that you've mischaracterized what I'm saying. Again, we don't even know if Kevtris gets paid for each unit produced which is another thing I would not assume.
I'm just reigning in assumptions and helping us form more informed expectations.