No the correct answer is that it rolls over. I just confirmed this. So not sure how you want to handle that.
Honor system?, or anyone that rolls it gets first place points.
I'm not sure how many are going to be able to do that anyway. If all 3 top scores do, i'll be super impressed.
My NES collection count: 757 games (16 to go for a full set)
Latest Purchase(s): Snow Brothers
"Wait...Bimmy and Jimmy?? How'd they make a mistake like this!? Bimmy isn't even a real name!"
Beware the Bimmy Marsh!
Proud owner of post #2000, #2900, and #3800 in Inner Circle HQ thread
Doesn't happen like that, though. It's not easy to roll most 2600 games. Others, like Journey Escape, are easier to roll, but you have to be pretty insane to sit through it that long. It's actually probably the most popular HSC on the internet, and not everyone wins, no. The scoring system is quite even throughout, but the winners are always varied. So, for example:
http://www.atariage.com/forums/topic/185463-high-score-club-...
You can see no one rolled that time. Whereas here:
http://www.atariage.com/forums/topic/180725-high-score-club-...
Only one game was rolled. Megamania had three total, but if you read the scoring for this particular week, its scores are left at base value because it was an easier game to do it. Doesn't happen often anyway and depends on the game.