Originally posted by: Brock Landers
Originally posted by: TheFinder
Originally posted by: Brock Landers
The Giver. Bought it for my boys and then decided I may as well read it for reference since I never did back in the '90s. Way too brief, but then again I guess it is a childrens book.
Are you aware there are 3 other books in the "series"? They aren't direct sequels per se, but they take place in the same world and have some interactions with each other. I just started rereading The Giver Quartet as something to pick up and read in snippets while my twins are playing and are leaving me alone.
Yes, they're even plugged in the back of the edition I have. But the seemingly lukewarm scores on goodreads, the review I saw on youtube, and the short summaries I skimmed online all kind of make me want to treat The Giver as standalone.
Again, late on this, but I reread
The Giver Quartet (The Giver, Gathering Blue, Messenger, and
Son). My wife had just read them for the first time and wanted to talk to me about them. I could only remember the events of
The Giver since I had read it multiple times as a kid but had only heard of and read the others about 5 years ago, so I decided to reread them.
The Giver is definitely the best of the four, though I did enjoy the others. They all bring a different look at how a post-apocalyptic world might be while not getting too gory/gritty (they are for kids after all), and none of them are dependent on
The Giver, though there are references to it, and
Son makes a lot more sense if you've read
The Giver. Some of the problems/conflicts get resolved a bit too easily, though. Like in
Gathering Blue, it's clear that there are men who are manipulating others for personal gain and either killing or otherwise silencing anyone who questions them or hints at what they're doing. The main character decides it's her mission to fight back at the end of the book. When
Messenger begins, several years have passed, and it's stated that things are much better in the village. Lame.
Even so, I'd recommend them if you'd enjoy an easy read with pretty engaging characters and stories. Just don't expect amazing literature. If you'd rather just stick with
The Giver, though, that's fine. You're not missing out.
-------------------------
To the Finder...
The Isle of Koholint is but an illusion...
Human, monster, sea, sky...
A scene on the lid of a sleeper's eye...
Awake the dreamer, and Koholint will vanish much like a bubble on a needle...
Cast-away, you should know the Truth!
My FS/WTB threads: http://nintendoage.com/forum/mess...