Which games are the two that you added? lol

New play asia chiptune cart and a super famicom side scroller. The super fami one looked real nice. 
 

Round 37. And... price!
The Grind	Crossfire (Variant)	Earthbound: 25th
$100	$65	$125
Starkeeper	Super Maruo (Variant)	Game On Retro Champ
$145	$110	$75
Gorf	Hotman (Variant)	NWC 25th
$105	$85	$140
The Grind	Super Maruo	Zelda: GoW RCG
$35	$100	$260
Journey	King of Demons	Zelda: PW RCG
$95	$210	$215
Airball	Dragon Quest III, TW	New Punchout, TW
$65	$100	$210
Sudoku	Mega Man Ultra	Metroid Deluxe, TW
$110	$80	$250
Pirate's Booty	Bahamut Lagoo, TW	Mystic Ark, TW
$185	$65	$60
8-Bit Xmas 2012	Mega Man: Battle of Gamma, TW	Tales of Phantasia
$95	$75	$100
8-Bit Xmas 2010	SMW: Return to Dino, TW	Tales of Phantasia
$160	$85	$165
Flashboy Cart	The Firemen, TW	The Firemen, TW
$205	$85	$100
Space Squash	Earthbound Zero, TW	Starfor Weekend, TW
$170	$120	$125
Flashboy Cart	Shin Megami Tensei, TW	Hacksaw Wrestlemania
$205	$260	$115
Blox	Terrinigma, TW	Hacksaw Wrestlemania
$105	$450	$85
Flashboy CIB	Moon8 and The Wall	Hacksaw Wrestlemania
$250	$120	$70
Fishbone	MidiNES	Hacksaw Wrestlemania
$115	$325	$70
Faceball Remastered	Star Ocean, TW	Hacksaw Wrestlemania
$145	$275	$75
Bound High	Splatterhouse, TW	Hacksaw Wrestlemania
$120	$260	$80
Faceball Prototype	Baleful Sonata
$105	$160

Games added. Now just to update prices finally on the OP... ugh.

• Tortoises (Cowlitz Edition)
• Tortoises (NA Edition)
• Almost Hero
• Almost Hero (Proto LE)
• Log Jammers
• 8 Bit Music Power Final (Famicom)
• Unholy Night (SNES)
• Unholy Night (Super Famicom)
• Kaizou Choujin Shubibinman Zero (Super Famicom)
• Haunted: Halloween '85 (Famicom)
• Haunted: Halloween '86 (Famicom)
• Black Box Challenge
• Black Box Challenge (LE)
• Black Box Challenge (NA)
• VGBS Cart
• JP Ronny
• Route 16
• Gremlins
• Sonson
• NWC Replica (Gold)
• NWC Replica (Grey)
• Four
• Zombie Hunter
• Zombie Hunter (Variant)
• Tower of Druaga
• Tower of Druaga (Variant)
• Binary Land
• Binary Land (Variant)
• Wrestlemania: Hardcore Holly Edition
• Wrestlemania: Hacksaw Jim Dug
• Ninja II
• Metroid: Rogue Dawn
• Zelda II: New Adventure
• Final Fantasy Trilogy (Famicom)
• Retroplayer.nl 2016 (Grey)
• Retroplayer.nl 2016 (Orange)
• Retroplayer.nl 2016 (Silver)
• Retroplayer.nl 2016 (Gold)
• Eskimo Bob (Grey)
• Eskimo Bob (LE)
• Wonderland Dizzy
• Wonderland Dizzy (White)
• Mystic Origins
• Dreamworld Pogie
• Escape 2042
• Wisdom Tree Collection
• RBI 2017
• KGJ17
• TSB2018
• TSB2018 (Green)
• TSBC18
• TNB18
• TSBIII18
• TSB18
• Super Mario Logic

Maybe one or two others... Took forever. And I still need to update prices. Oh, fiddlesticks.

The price guide has been updated to reflect the sales from the past year.

I also added some games that were missing, or maybe I have named something I couldn't find, like:

• Happily Ever After
• Hyper Metroid by Advanced Pillow

Added some more games. Mostly one offs that I saw in thesubcon3's new book.

• DrunkenNES
• Computers are Easy, Love is Kind
• Hot Seat Harry
• RNDM - I couldn't find it, might be listed twice.
• Retro Spels Massan
• Urban Acid Zombies
• Racoon Ranger
• Iron Commando (LE)
• Legend (LE)

And of course, always possible I added another one or two and forgot.

Is Ultimate frogger champion still $100?

A lot of the old Retrozone stuff that is discontinued now I don't see for secondary sales like I used to. With the exception of E.T., which is more current, there are a handful of titles that I haven't seen up for sale in a long time. If there aren't any copies available on Ebay, then I'd say that's a safe bet ($100).
 

Glad to see someone took over for me when I kinda fell out of the scene. Tis a hard and thankless job lol.

I actually was over on your site earlier this month doing research for something and chuckled thinking about you. Hope all is well, sir. Someday we should sit and chat over BEvERages.
 

What about Chip's challenge? It's not available any longer I thought?

Project pal? Chip tune cart.

Are you answering a question I can't see?
 

Oh sorry.
i did not see this one on the list and was just asking 
I don't know if it counts or not either.
i was just wondering the current values it has sold for if anyone knew.  

 

I've got it listed as PAL Project. Been a while since one sold. I have it at $100. 
 

Ok cool. Thanks.

Not sure if you've seen this one yet, but it's a remake of Heiankyo Alien for the Famicom by Columbus Circle called Neo Heiankyo Alien.
It's available on PlayAsia for $50 USD: https://www.play-asia.com/neo-hei...

I have a few on this list that are looking for a good home.

http://vintage.nintendoage.com/fo...

I assume these prices are suppose to reflect how they were sold, ie including manual, box, whatever it shipped with?

Indeed, that is how this guide works.
 

Alright, so this list is something like six months or so stale. I may have to rethink what exactly it is I want to achieve. The pricing may have to go in favor of keeping a true list of all Aftermarket Games. I mean, I feel like there is a solid average for anyone to go off of from here on out, with the data to back up those numbers if needed in this thread. That was my original goal, stomp out people who suggested prices that were too high when I was trying to buy stuff.

Part of the reason I want to stop pricing was because of issues I was having with eBay at the beginning of the year. Our workaround for getting true pricing for OBOs was routed by them, which meant those auctions were no longer viable for pricing. I'm including the last update I was working on when I realized this.

EDIT: I actually had a window of nothing but auctions open since Feb. Added those to this update.

 

Round 38. And... price!
BO/BIN
Hyper Fighting	Journey	Dragon Quest 1&2, TW
$565	$90	$265
Metroid Deluxe	Earthbound, TW	Larry
$180	$40	$110
BLOX	Space Squash	Space Pinball
$275	$210	$210
Anamanaguchi	Action 53 Volume 1	Star Keeper, RE
$100	$100	$300
GlitchNES	Challenger #49/50	Holly Jolly
$80	$80	$100
Glider	Metroid Redesign Big Box	Final Fantasy 6, TW
$90	$1,000	$85
Mega Man Ultra	Zelda: Outlands, TW	Rendering Ranger
$350	$205	$200
Zelda: Outlands, TW	Dragon Quest 6, TW	Terranigma, TW
$160	$160	$200
Uforce Power Games	Nomolos, RZ	SMB2j
$300	$90	$175
DK Pie Factory	Castlevania: Blood Moon	Challenger
$85	$55	$80
Ultimate Frogger	DK Pie Factory	Metal Force
$125	$95	$70
Bound High
$200
BIDS
Fishbone	Vegavox	16 Bit Xmas 2011
$80	$45	$125
Metroid Deluxe	Chuck Yeager	Live a Live, TW
$115	$60	$200
Tortoises (2nd Edition)	Vegavox	Mario & Wario
$50	$45	$115
Time Diver Eon Man	Mario Adventure, TW	Mystic Quest Reborn
$90	$160	$230
Ducktales Gold AP	MidiNES	Mystic Ark
$1,300	$220	$195
DBZ Saiya Densetsu TW	Star Ocean, TW	Treasure of Rudras
$75	$230	$160
Bahamut Lagoon	Violinist of Hamelin, TW	Mr. Gimmick, TW
$170	$250	$120
Stadium Events, TW	Mario Adventure, TW	Tales of Phantasia
$660	$160	$145
Treasure of the Rudras, TW	Star Fox 2, TW	Mystic Ark, TW
$200	$200	$190
Return to Dino Land, TW	Front Mission, TW	Adventures of Hourai High, TW
$185	$275	$185
Asterix & Obelix, TW	Dragon Quest 1&2	Terranigma, TW
$210	$170	$250
Mystic Quest, TW	Zelda Parallel Worlds, TW	Star Ocean, TW
$230	$185	$235
Final Fantasy VI, TW	Chrono Trigger Crimson Echoes, TW	Treasure Hunter G, TW
$145	$200	$200
Back to the Future Part II, TW	Famicom Detective Club II, TW	Dragon Quest 5, TW
$195	$180	$180
Dragon Quest 6, TW	Mario and Wario	King of Demons, TW
$175	$115	$340
Pirate Booty	16 Bit Xmas 2011	8 Bit Xmas 2009
$100	$110	$150
16 Bit Xmas 2012	Megam and Bass, RCG	Goddess of Wisdom, RCG
$125	$330	$90
Parellel Worlds, RCG	Goddess of Wisdom, RCG	Marvelous, RCG
$100	$135	$230
Adventure of Link, RCG	Shadowhawk, RCG	Shadowhawk, RCG
$160	$210	$90
Shawdowhawk, RCG
$500

I have a Nintendo Pocket limited edition Ice Blue. Is it rare and worth anything?

Another update. Prices aren't reflected in the OP. Have a bunch of games I need to add, too.

 

Round 39. And... price!
BO/BIN
MidiNES	Moon8	Journey
$275	$300	$90
Lizard (White)	Mege Man Ultra, TW	Watman
$110	$210	$110
Vigilante 2	Lizard (White)	Anamanaguchi
$50	$75	$155
Faceball	E.T.	Hyper Fighting
$210	$50	$295
Lizard (White)	Lizard (White)	Insecticide
$60	$70	$250
Tailgate Party	8 Bit Xmas 2011	SMW: Dino Land
$35	$260	$145
Secret of Mana 2, TW	SMW: Dino Land	Super Metroid Redesign
$305	$355	$270
Super Metroid: Axeil Edition	Quest Forge (LE)	VS Castlevania
$190	$60	$130
VS SMB	8 Bit Xmas 2011	Final Fantasy 2, 4, 6
$100	$260	$250
Secret of Mana 2, TW	Chrono Trigger Crimson Echoes, TW	Zelda: Goddess of Wisdom
$100	$220	$330
Treasure of Rudras, TW	The Fireman, TW	Mega Man and Bass
$315	$175	$380
Zelda: Parallel Worlds Remodel, TW	Zelda: Outlands, TW	Final Fntasy Set, TW
$145	$275	$1,015
Choas World, TW	Zelda Outlands
$225	$400
BIDS
Action53 Volume 2	Vegavox 2	Moon8
$40	$75	$130
MidiNES	MidiNES	Super Maruo
$255	$205	$35
Super Maruo	Ninja Slap	Kevin Power #28/50
$60	$80	$65
Germ Squashers	Silcon Statue	Perfect Pair
$115	$35	$25
Blow 'em Out #9/100	Journey #27/50	3-in-1 2p Pak
$35	$80	$100
Sudoku (Gold)	Freefall	Mystic Quest Reborn Lite #43/50
$125	$65	$40
Mystic Quest Reborn Lite #40/50	Mystic Quest Reborn Lite	Super Metroid Redesign (Big Box)
$40	$40	$150
Mario Xmas Rekringled (1/5)	Hoppin Mad	Mike Ditka's BPF
$105	$55	$55
Mystic Quest Reborn Lite	Zelda: Parallel Worlds, RCG	Marvelous, RCG
$40	$155	$460
Zelda: Goddess of Wisdom	Airball	VS Super Mario Bros
$160	$55	$105
Pirate Booty	Don Doko Don	All New Punch Out!, TW
$70	$110	$210
Zelda: Parallel Worlds Remodel, TW	SMW Dino Land, TW	Famidepth
$100	$115	$150
Freddy vs Jason	Rygar (Black Box)	MTPO (Black Box)
$105	$35	$80
Lion King	SMB3 Mix	MTPO (Black Box)
$65	$155	$85
New Punch Out (Black Box)	Chips Challenge (Gold)	War on Wheels
$35	$50	$35
Shoot UFO	New Punch Out (Black Box)	Battle City (Black Box)
$50	$55	$50
Flappy (Black Box)	Crossfire (Black Box)	Spy vs Spy
$40	$35	$70
F-1 Race (Black Box)	Circus Charlie
$50	$30

Lol. Why don't you go out on ebay, type in nintendo gameboy pocket ice blue and see what happens?!?!?

Hey man... thank you for keeping this thread alive. I've only just started getting into repros... it's an expensive time to be doing that.
i think i can find a few copies of dragon warrior to trade you if you're willing to part with your precious repros! lol