Originally posted by: jonebone
Well considering their literal cash value per share is $4.90, yes a $3.50 a share value is laughable. If they shut their doors tomorrow and liquidated every single thing they'd pull $6+ a share easy.
Either way, the next generation being backwards compatible props up the used game market. GME nixed the dividend but bought back around $23M in shares at $5.20. Thatd exactly what you want to see, a company who puts money where there mouth is. They also sold off all those phone related businesses and decided to focus on their core of video games.
So yes, $3.50 is absolutely laughable. I'm not putting anymore money into what had panned out to be a bad investment. Thankfully retro video games have done quite well for me this year, as ironic as that is.
Ok, here's my take, and I really need to read their 2Q financials before getting into more detail, but..
The liquidation price is only one factor in the current stock price. If the company announced tomorrow that it was going to liquidate, the market would immediately revalue the company. Until then, it's priced as a going concern. No one is valuing, say, APPL, as if it's going to shut its doors tomorrow. The market is hammering GME since, despite their best efforts, it's attempting to be an ongoing concern.
I'm curious at how you got $6 liquidation value, BTW. They have to settle substrantial outstanding debt in a receivership situation, and their assets would likely not go for full market values.
Having that much cash around as fraction of company value is actually a big concern in my view. It demonstrates the company has no solid strategy on how to invest its equity. A lot of the cash on hand will likely go to paying off their 2021 debt tranche.
Buying back 12 million shares of stock at 5.20 - 6.00 when the stock is now $3.50? Brilliant!
So I guess we have been viewing the same variables (abnormally high dividend [until it disappeared], company strategy, equity position) and drawing very different conclusions. We should check back at year end and see where things stand. I'll read their financial statements in detail in the next week or two when I have some time.