If so, where's Gaby Jay? Looks like a good guy to me. He wouldn’t hurt anybody!

 

For the love of God, PLEASE tell me more about Shadow Mask, your own original character!

I am going crazy not knowing his powerset, backstory, and relationship with the other characters!

I promise I WON'T STEAL!

It’s not all of the good guys, many are omitted. And many who are not in Nintendo series are included. Read the OP more carefully. I am genuinely confused about what the poster is trying to do, and I don’t think I’m alone. So some people are being funny in their responses, I don’t think it’s mean. 
 

There needs to be some representation from the Mario and Luigi Series! You forgot such memorable characters such as Blablanadon, the Hammerhead Bros, Prince Peasly, Queen Bean, Lady Lima. There's also a bunch of characters from the Mario RPG game, Mallow and Geno who come to mind. I also saw that you started listing off some of the paper mario characters, you forgot Captain Bobbery from the thousand year door. Also, I found it funny that you mentioned Oogtar, if you are adding characters from the super show, you gotta have Captain Lou Albano, because he's the best mario...

And to the people questioning the point of this, I've come to realize there is no point, it's just a list. Alternatively, there's this as well: https://mario.fandom.com/wiki/Cat...

If OP’s last thread is any indication, it’s just an arbitrary list of what he wants to include. I’m unclear why he made a similar thread, at the same time as well. I don’t think people are being mean either, as long as the mods keep these threads open, people are going to playfully play along and try to suss out what this is, because it isn’t an exhaustive list and doesn’t neatly fit OP’s own definition.

 

We need detective hybrid on the case.

A shout out for Professor Hector................ The true master of R. O. B.

Are you 100% sure?

 

Thank you!

Cross my heart and hope to die, dude!  
 

I'm not telling you.

Don't listen to him dude, he is just trying to buy your drawers. 
 

Awww... Come on man! PLEASE! Pretty please, with, like, sugar on top?!

Optout said please, that means you are legally obligated by the rules of I don't know. Can't do that man! If you are gonna throw this stuff out there, you gotta give us some sort of hint. I found some *interesting* stuff online on what it could be, so I have an idea...

 

I can't wait to read more! Where's the webpage with her stories??

Actually, there isn't one. It never came into fruition.
 

Sorry to hear that! But, don't give up! If you can make this work and get her stories online someday, I will be your first fan!  
 

Thank you.
 

Most excellent!

Thank you!

Welcome!

Excellent breakdown of each game. 

I particularily like your commitment to not giving a fuck what anyone else thinks. You do you!

This is a list of The Video Game Masters, not the games.

 

Gotcha! And I dig it!

I'm glad you do!