Originally posted by: Gloves
Originally posted by: toma
Got mine in the mail today. Initial impressions are a little mixed to be honest. It's definitely responsive, but I'm not a big fan of the ergonomics. It feels kind of big, flat, and hollow. I think I would've preferred the classic rectangle without the grips to be honest. The grips just aren't working for me. They're flat and stick out to the sides instead of angled backwards like a modern controller, so instead of being comfortable, they just kind of feel in the way. They also make the top corners feel more prominent than on a normal NES controller somehow... I dunno... Something just feels off about it. Sorry. I wanted to like this so bad, but it just doesn't fit my hands at all. The other thing about it is that it's incredibly loud, and the buttons have very little travel when pressing them, but that's just likely years of experience with membrane controllers talking.
One of my gripes is the noise. It's fine during the day with the music going but with my insomnia I'm often up later than my wife with the music turned down, and this controller is so loud when nothing else is making noise that I played worse just because I was subconsciously trying to press buttons less.
Also, for shmups (the genre I play most by far) it's honestly not great. I'll have to give it more time to be sure but thus far the d-pad is not smooth enough to make the minute movements that are required for high level shmup play. I'm sure with tetris where you click click click click the d-pad to move it's fine, but I need to go from holding it down directly to tapping and then back, and the d-pad seems to be primarily built for either tapping, or holding it in for long periods, not alternating between the two. An analog will likely still be my go-to for shmups, and sadly I've yet to find a really solid one for the NES.
Hate to say I completely agree. I love Retrousb products, but am honestly disappointed in the controller, especially considering the high price. Overall, functionally speaking it gets the job done and it doesn't seem to have lag. However, the controller overall sort of feels like a prototype. It's unexpectedly rather loud, the explanation of every button sounding like a mouse click is spot on. I'm just not sure I'm going to get used to the microswitches either, particularly with the dpad. I think they'd be great for Tetris, but trying to play Pac-Man I was severely disappointed. Idk, with a lifetime of quiet controllers with smoother rubber/plastic dpads and buttons, just not sure I can adjust and be comfortable playing certain games with it.
Ending rant here, overall I will continue to use it to see if my feelings change, but the first impressions were rather rough (as in if I were at a store test driving, I would not have purchased). Just honest feedback for folks, given the price of this thing.